{
  "schema": "persistent-memory.portfolio-demo.comparison.v1",
  "scenario": "project-atlas-deadline-v1",
  "synthetic": true,
  "generated_at_utc": "2026-10-20T18:46:47.247218Z",
  "core_trace": {
    "schema": "persistent-memory.portfolio-demo.trace.v1",
    "scenario": "project-atlas-deadline-v1",
    "synthetic": true,
    "generated_at_utc": "2026-10-20T18:46:47.247218Z",
    "provenance": {
      "base_commit": "c2546be8abb05aadd518fb143d040cec0c4769a9",
      "package": "hermes-memory-core",
      "installed_version": "0.3.0a2",
      "script_sha256": "3c3cbdbc3916d155d390c96aedef55043e077704593afdb59a2807f8d6501f3e",
      "modules": {
        "core.py": "5ad093031bb061360c616ed44ab321499f3765b7e887928d073ee20ed6a37bb0"
      }
    },
    "events": [
      {
        "id": 1,
        "phase": "admit",
        "operations": [
          "register_source",
          "read"
        ],
        "refs": {
          "date_v1": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
            "version_id": "c290ec3322dc48bc8d4c042a5be45de7"
          },
          "control": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
            "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0"
          }
        },
        "reads": {
          "date_v1": {
            "allowed": true,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
              "version_id": "c290ec3322dc48bc8d4c042a5be45de7"
            },
            "content": "Projet Atlas : livraison vendredi.",
            "content_sha256": "4118120a9c8c4cb6c992bfed64e115841e4785381a9eee3c30997fe924967da2",
            "reason": "allowed",
            "alias": null
          },
          "control": {
            "allowed": true,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
              "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0"
            },
            "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française.",
            "content_sha256": "8741943a03fa36d8d9eabfb540f080934cc4b79ecea11e830bd410744190abda",
            "reason": "allowed",
            "alias": null
          }
        },
        "details": {},
        "provenance": null
      },
      {
        "id": 2,
        "phase": "derive",
        "operations": [
          "derive",
          "read",
          "explain_artifact"
        ],
        "refs": {
          "date_v1": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
            "version_id": "c290ec3322dc48bc8d4c042a5be45de7"
          },
          "control": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
            "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0"
          },
          "brief_v1": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
            "version_id": "37c2519ef4f9406fb29a67910bf7a5a9"
          }
        },
        "reads": {
          "brief_v1": {
            "allowed": true,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
              "version_id": "37c2519ef4f9406fb29a67910bf7a5a9"
            },
            "content": "Brief Atlas — Projet Atlas : livraison vendredi. Projet Atlas : langue de communication française.",
            "content_sha256": "02fcca55c35bb4543d7ad8a41bebe444c115d0a1931e73ebdcc066e37e23ee5c",
            "reason": "allowed",
            "alias": null
          }
        },
        "details": {},
        "provenance": {
          "root": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
            "version_id": "37c2519ef4f9406fb29a67910bf7a5a9"
          },
          "nodes": [
            {
              "ref": {
                "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
                "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
                "version_id": "37c2519ef4f9406fb29a67910bf7a5a9"
              },
              "allowed": true,
              "reason": "allowed",
              "dependencies": [
                {
                  "ref": {
                    "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
                    "version_id": "c290ec3322dc48bc8d4c042a5be45de7",
                    "workspace": "portfolio-atlas"
                  },
                  "relation": "derives"
                },
                {
                  "ref": {
                    "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
                    "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0",
                    "workspace": "portfolio-atlas"
                  },
                  "relation": "derives"
                }
              ],
              "provenance_known": true,
              "producer": null,
              "retention": {
                "policy": "manual_indefinite",
                "automatic_physical_purge": false
              }
            },
            {
              "ref": {
                "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
                "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0",
                "workspace": "portfolio-atlas"
              },
              "allowed": true,
              "reason": "allowed",
              "dependencies": [],
              "provenance_known": true,
              "producer": null,
              "retention": {
                "policy": "manual_indefinite",
                "automatic_physical_purge": false
              }
            },
            {
              "ref": {
                "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
                "version_id": "c290ec3322dc48bc8d4c042a5be45de7",
                "workspace": "portfolio-atlas"
              },
              "allowed": true,
              "reason": "allowed",
              "dependencies": [],
              "provenance_known": true,
              "producer": null,
              "retention": {
                "policy": "manual_indefinite",
                "automatic_physical_purge": false
              }
            }
          ],
          "coverage": "known_dependencies_only"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": 3,
        "phase": "correct",
        "operations": [
          "register_source",
          "read",
          "derive",
          "open",
          "backup",
          "explain_artifact"
        ],
        "refs": {
          "date_v1": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
            "version_id": "c290ec3322dc48bc8d4c042a5be45de7"
          },
          "date_v2": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
            "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e"
          },
          "control": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
            "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0"
          },
          "brief_v1": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
            "version_id": "37c2519ef4f9406fb29a67910bf7a5a9"
          },
          "brief_v2": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
            "version_id": "3438f9a4324d43db8a7170e5de3d4478"
          }
        },
        "reads": {
          "old_date": {
            "allowed": false,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
              "version_id": "c290ec3322dc48bc8d4c042a5be45de7"
            },
            "reason": "version_not_current"
          },
          "old_brief_before_replacement": {
            "allowed": false,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
              "version_id": "37c2519ef4f9406fb29a67910bf7a5a9"
            },
            "reason": "version_not_current"
          },
          "date_v2": {
            "allowed": true,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
              "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e"
            },
            "content": "Projet Atlas : livraison lundi.",
            "content_sha256": "642982ca12af2c09d877d5282c90717b65c047b89dad936b209bc967036d25ef",
            "reason": "allowed",
            "alias": null
          },
          "control": {
            "allowed": true,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
              "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0"
            },
            "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française.",
            "content_sha256": "8741943a03fa36d8d9eabfb540f080934cc4b79ecea11e830bd410744190abda",
            "reason": "allowed",
            "alias": null
          },
          "brief_v2": {
            "allowed": true,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
              "version_id": "3438f9a4324d43db8a7170e5de3d4478"
            },
            "content": "Brief Atlas — Projet Atlas : livraison lundi. Projet Atlas : langue de communication française.",
            "content_sha256": "de5e8bef42b39887b94fbec8e734a598efc71c101ace4d1b0f3f314a5e8d8e38",
            "reason": "allowed",
            "alias": null
          },
          "reopened_brief": {
            "allowed": true,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
              "version_id": "3438f9a4324d43db8a7170e5de3d4478"
            },
            "content": "Brief Atlas — Projet Atlas : livraison lundi. Projet Atlas : langue de communication française.",
            "content_sha256": "de5e8bef42b39887b94fbec8e734a598efc71c101ace4d1b0f3f314a5e8d8e38",
            "reason": "allowed",
            "alias": null
          }
        },
        "details": {
          "expected_version": "c290ec3322dc48bc8d4c042a5be45de7",
          "storage_reopened": true,
          "backup_quarantined": true,
          "backup_checkpoint": {
            "generation": "5dc478b05a7142e79980345461d86877",
            "epoch": 5,
            "digest": "3448047c1e4fe199b6a34290979ef9830a1a4b3aa09839dc71ce50bde100398d"
          }
        },
        "provenance": {
          "root": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
            "version_id": "3438f9a4324d43db8a7170e5de3d4478"
          },
          "nodes": [
            {
              "ref": {
                "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
                "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
                "version_id": "3438f9a4324d43db8a7170e5de3d4478"
              },
              "allowed": true,
              "reason": "allowed",
              "dependencies": [
                {
                  "ref": {
                    "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
                    "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e",
                    "workspace": "portfolio-atlas"
                  },
                  "relation": "derives"
                },
                {
                  "ref": {
                    "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
                    "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0",
                    "workspace": "portfolio-atlas"
                  },
                  "relation": "derives"
                }
              ],
              "provenance_known": true,
              "producer": null,
              "retention": {
                "policy": "manual_indefinite",
                "automatic_physical_purge": false
              }
            },
            {
              "ref": {
                "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
                "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0",
                "workspace": "portfolio-atlas"
              },
              "allowed": true,
              "reason": "allowed",
              "dependencies": [],
              "provenance_known": true,
              "producer": null,
              "retention": {
                "policy": "manual_indefinite",
                "automatic_physical_purge": false
              }
            },
            {
              "ref": {
                "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
                "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e",
                "workspace": "portfolio-atlas"
              },
              "allowed": true,
              "reason": "allowed",
              "dependencies": [],
              "provenance_known": true,
              "producer": null,
              "retention": {
                "policy": "manual_indefinite",
                "automatic_physical_purge": false
              }
            }
          ],
          "coverage": "known_dependencies_only"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": 4,
        "phase": "revoke",
        "operations": [
          "revoke_source",
          "read",
          "explain_artifact"
        ],
        "refs": {
          "date_v2": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
            "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e"
          },
          "control": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
            "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0"
          },
          "brief_v2": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
            "version_id": "3438f9a4324d43db8a7170e5de3d4478"
          }
        },
        "reads": {
          "date_v2": {
            "allowed": false,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
              "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e"
            },
            "reason": "source_revoked"
          },
          "brief_v2": {
            "allowed": false,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
              "version_id": "3438f9a4324d43db8a7170e5de3d4478"
            },
            "reason": "source_revoked"
          },
          "control": {
            "allowed": true,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
              "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0"
            },
            "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française.",
            "content_sha256": "8741943a03fa36d8d9eabfb540f080934cc4b79ecea11e830bd410744190abda",
            "reason": "allowed",
            "alias": null
          }
        },
        "details": {
          "withdrawal": {
            "event_id": "atlas-withdraw-deadline",
            "epoch": 6,
            "registered": true,
            "covered_reads_blocked": true,
            "projection_purge": "pending",
            "coverage": "known_dependencies_only",
            "physical_erasure": false
          }
        },
        "provenance": {
          "root": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
            "version_id": "3438f9a4324d43db8a7170e5de3d4478"
          },
          "nodes": [
            {
              "ref": {
                "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
                "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
                "version_id": "3438f9a4324d43db8a7170e5de3d4478"
              },
              "allowed": false,
              "reason": "source_revoked",
              "dependencies": [
                {
                  "ref": {
                    "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
                    "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e",
                    "workspace": "portfolio-atlas"
                  },
                  "relation": "derives"
                },
                {
                  "ref": {
                    "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
                    "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0",
                    "workspace": "portfolio-atlas"
                  },
                  "relation": "derives"
                }
              ],
              "provenance_known": true,
              "producer": null,
              "retention": {
                "policy": "manual_indefinite",
                "automatic_physical_purge": false
              }
            },
            {
              "ref": {
                "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
                "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0",
                "workspace": "portfolio-atlas"
              },
              "allowed": true,
              "reason": "allowed",
              "dependencies": [],
              "provenance_known": true,
              "producer": null,
              "retention": {
                "policy": "manual_indefinite",
                "automatic_physical_purge": false
              }
            },
            {
              "ref": {
                "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
                "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e",
                "workspace": "portfolio-atlas"
              },
              "allowed": false,
              "reason": "source_revoked",
              "dependencies": [],
              "provenance_known": true,
              "producer": null,
              "retention": {
                "policy": "manual_indefinite",
                "automatic_physical_purge": false
              }
            }
          ],
          "coverage": "known_dependencies_only"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": 5,
        "phase": "restore",
        "operations": [
          "open",
          "read",
          "restore_verify",
          "explain_artifact"
        ],
        "refs": {
          "date_v1": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
            "version_id": "c290ec3322dc48bc8d4c042a5be45de7"
          },
          "date_v2": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
            "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e"
          },
          "control": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
            "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0"
          },
          "brief_v2": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
            "version_id": "3438f9a4324d43db8a7170e5de3d4478"
          }
        },
        "reads": {
          "quarantined_control": {
            "allowed": false,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
              "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0"
            },
            "reason": "authority_or_store_unavailable"
          },
          "date_v1": {
            "allowed": false,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
              "version_id": "c290ec3322dc48bc8d4c042a5be45de7"
            },
            "reason": "source_revoked"
          },
          "date_v2": {
            "allowed": false,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
              "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e"
            },
            "reason": "source_revoked"
          },
          "brief_v2": {
            "allowed": false,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
              "version_id": "3438f9a4324d43db8a7170e5de3d4478"
            },
            "reason": "source_revoked"
          },
          "control": {
            "allowed": true,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
              "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0"
            },
            "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française.",
            "content_sha256": "8741943a03fa36d8d9eabfb540f080934cc4b79ecea11e830bd410744190abda",
            "reason": "allowed",
            "alias": null
          }
        },
        "details": {
          "retained_current_authority": true,
          "restoration": {
            "ready": true,
            "checkpoint": {
              "generation": "5dc478b05a7142e79980345461d86877",
              "epoch": 6,
              "digest": "fd3ee520ef86ef8feff58cb3d4db485b956602ee337cf93b5822999f64cac8f2"
            },
            "missing_current_content": [],
            "blocked": [
              {
                "ref": {
                  "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
                  "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
                  "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e"
                },
                "reason": "source_revoked"
              },
              {
                "ref": {
                  "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
                  "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
                  "version_id": "3438f9a4324d43db8a7170e5de3d4478"
                },
                "reason": "source_revoked"
              }
            ],
            "coverage": "known_dependencies_only"
          }
        },
        "provenance": {
          "root": {
            "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
            "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
            "version_id": "3438f9a4324d43db8a7170e5de3d4478"
          },
          "nodes": [
            {
              "ref": {
                "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
                "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
                "version_id": "3438f9a4324d43db8a7170e5de3d4478"
              },
              "allowed": false,
              "reason": "source_revoked",
              "dependencies": [
                {
                  "ref": {
                    "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
                    "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e",
                    "workspace": "portfolio-atlas"
                  },
                  "relation": "derives"
                },
                {
                  "ref": {
                    "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
                    "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0",
                    "workspace": "portfolio-atlas"
                  },
                  "relation": "derives"
                }
              ],
              "provenance_known": true,
              "producer": null,
              "retention": {
                "policy": "manual_indefinite",
                "automatic_physical_purge": false
              }
            },
            {
              "ref": {
                "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
                "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0",
                "workspace": "portfolio-atlas"
              },
              "allowed": true,
              "reason": "allowed",
              "dependencies": [],
              "provenance_known": true,
              "producer": null,
              "retention": {
                "policy": "manual_indefinite",
                "automatic_physical_purge": false
              }
            },
            {
              "ref": {
                "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
                "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e",
                "workspace": "portfolio-atlas"
              },
              "allowed": false,
              "reason": "source_revoked",
              "dependencies": [],
              "provenance_known": true,
              "producer": null,
              "retention": {
                "policy": "manual_indefinite",
                "automatic_physical_purge": false
              }
            }
          ],
          "coverage": "known_dependencies_only"
        }
      }
    ],
    "assertions": {
      "initial_sources_allowed": true,
      "initial_brief_allowed": true,
      "initial_exact_dependencies": true,
      "correction_new_version": true,
      "old_date_denied": true,
      "old_brief_denied_before_replacement": true,
      "corrected_date_and_control_allowed": true,
      "corrected_brief_allowed_after_storage_reopen": true,
      "withdrawn_date_denied": true,
      "dependent_brief_denied": true,
      "independent_control_preserved": true,
      "old_content_restore_denied_before_verification": true,
      "old_and_current_withdrawn_versions_stay_denied": true,
      "restored_dependent_brief_stays_denied": true,
      "restored_independent_control_allowed": true,
      "no_missing_current_content": true
    },
    "boundaries": [
      "synthetic_application_example_without_model_or_network_calls",
      "storage_reopen_not_process_or_hardware_crash_simulation",
      "known_declared_dependencies_only",
      "current_authority_and_freshness_witness_retained_outside_content_backup",
      "coordinated_authority_and_witness_rollback_not_covered",
      "logical_read_revocation_not_physical_erasure_or_model_unlearning",
      "recorded_run_not_a_reliability_or_latency_benchmark"
    ]
  },
  "reference": {
    "contract": {
      "name": "key-value-cache-without-dependency-tracking",
      "writes": "replace_the_addressed_key_only",
      "briefs": "application_stores_the_same_explicitly_rebuilt_text_as_the_core",
      "dependencies": "received_in_operation_receipts_but_not_stored_or_revalidated",
      "withdrawal": "remove_the_addressed_source_key_only",
      "recovery": "restore_all_cache_content_from_its_pre_withdrawal_json_snapshot",
      "storage": "in_process_dictionary_with_real_json_snapshot_and_restore",
      "authority": "no_separate_revocation_authority_or_freshness_witness"
    },
    "receipts": [
      {
        "id": 1,
        "phase": "admit",
        "operation": "put",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-deadline",
          "content": "Projet Atlas : livraison vendredi.",
          "declared_dependencies": []
        },
        "result": {
          "replaced": false
        },
        "state_sha256": "81a9c2a9d0f7bd7d149cff6758578271098c878598d3ef21b8307eb8b21eae4e"
      },
      {
        "id": 2,
        "phase": "admit",
        "operation": "put",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-language",
          "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française.",
          "declared_dependencies": []
        },
        "result": {
          "replaced": false
        },
        "state_sha256": "8dfd6b56dd8413f8d1c9128bf89306b5d575cf63c6c76bd13d8c3fa72f62b23f"
      },
      {
        "id": 3,
        "phase": "derive",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-deadline"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": true,
          "reason": "cache_hit",
          "content": "Projet Atlas : livraison vendredi."
        },
        "state_sha256": "8dfd6b56dd8413f8d1c9128bf89306b5d575cf63c6c76bd13d8c3fa72f62b23f"
      },
      {
        "id": 4,
        "phase": "derive",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-brief"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": false,
          "reason": "cache_miss"
        },
        "state_sha256": "8dfd6b56dd8413f8d1c9128bf89306b5d575cf63c6c76bd13d8c3fa72f62b23f"
      },
      {
        "id": 5,
        "phase": "derive",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-language"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": true,
          "reason": "cache_hit",
          "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
        },
        "state_sha256": "8dfd6b56dd8413f8d1c9128bf89306b5d575cf63c6c76bd13d8c3fa72f62b23f"
      },
      {
        "id": 6,
        "phase": "derive",
        "operation": "put",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-brief",
          "content": "Brief Atlas — Projet Atlas : livraison vendredi. Projet Atlas : langue de communication française.",
          "declared_dependencies": [
            {
              "ref": {
                "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
                "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
                "version_id": "c290ec3322dc48bc8d4c042a5be45de7"
              },
              "relation": "derives"
            },
            {
              "ref": {
                "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
                "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
                "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0"
              },
              "relation": "derives"
            }
          ]
        },
        "result": {
          "replaced": false
        },
        "state_sha256": "73290e0d2186d154a7b1b68c2f97f7ae250e3aae0d9aafe0c4aa1f76c37313bd"
      },
      {
        "id": 7,
        "phase": "correct",
        "operation": "put",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-deadline",
          "content": "Projet Atlas : livraison lundi.",
          "declared_dependencies": []
        },
        "result": {
          "replaced": true
        },
        "state_sha256": "b7cce6c6f155453664c7680e778bb95f1f0ae133a55dcc10109f724ce9d3bb12"
      },
      {
        "id": 8,
        "phase": "correct",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-deadline"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": true,
          "reason": "cache_hit",
          "content": "Projet Atlas : livraison lundi."
        },
        "state_sha256": "b7cce6c6f155453664c7680e778bb95f1f0ae133a55dcc10109f724ce9d3bb12"
      },
      {
        "id": 9,
        "phase": "correct",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-brief"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": true,
          "reason": "cache_hit",
          "content": "Brief Atlas — Projet Atlas : livraison vendredi. Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
        },
        "state_sha256": "b7cce6c6f155453664c7680e778bb95f1f0ae133a55dcc10109f724ce9d3bb12"
      },
      {
        "id": 10,
        "phase": "correct",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-language"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": true,
          "reason": "cache_hit",
          "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
        },
        "state_sha256": "b7cce6c6f155453664c7680e778bb95f1f0ae133a55dcc10109f724ce9d3bb12"
      },
      {
        "id": 11,
        "phase": "correct",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-deadline"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": true,
          "reason": "cache_hit",
          "content": "Projet Atlas : livraison lundi."
        },
        "state_sha256": "b7cce6c6f155453664c7680e778bb95f1f0ae133a55dcc10109f724ce9d3bb12"
      },
      {
        "id": 12,
        "phase": "correct",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-brief"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": true,
          "reason": "cache_hit",
          "content": "Brief Atlas — Projet Atlas : livraison vendredi. Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
        },
        "state_sha256": "b7cce6c6f155453664c7680e778bb95f1f0ae133a55dcc10109f724ce9d3bb12"
      },
      {
        "id": 13,
        "phase": "correct",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-language"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": true,
          "reason": "cache_hit",
          "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
        },
        "state_sha256": "b7cce6c6f155453664c7680e778bb95f1f0ae133a55dcc10109f724ce9d3bb12"
      },
      {
        "id": 14,
        "phase": "correct",
        "operation": "put",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-brief",
          "content": "Brief Atlas — Projet Atlas : livraison lundi. Projet Atlas : langue de communication française.",
          "declared_dependencies": [
            {
              "ref": {
                "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
                "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
                "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e"
              },
              "relation": "derives"
            },
            {
              "ref": {
                "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
                "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
                "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0"
              },
              "relation": "derives"
            }
          ]
        },
        "result": {
          "replaced": true
        },
        "state_sha256": "1cdf589e7391badf7d1c38af770df79b2fb4757f2d028eba9937696a8fc860d3"
      },
      {
        "id": 15,
        "phase": "correct",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-deadline"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": true,
          "reason": "cache_hit",
          "content": "Projet Atlas : livraison lundi."
        },
        "state_sha256": "1cdf589e7391badf7d1c38af770df79b2fb4757f2d028eba9937696a8fc860d3"
      },
      {
        "id": 16,
        "phase": "correct",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-brief"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": true,
          "reason": "cache_hit",
          "content": "Brief Atlas — Projet Atlas : livraison lundi. Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
        },
        "state_sha256": "1cdf589e7391badf7d1c38af770df79b2fb4757f2d028eba9937696a8fc860d3"
      },
      {
        "id": 17,
        "phase": "correct",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-language"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": true,
          "reason": "cache_hit",
          "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
        },
        "state_sha256": "1cdf589e7391badf7d1c38af770df79b2fb4757f2d028eba9937696a8fc860d3"
      },
      {
        "id": 18,
        "phase": "correct",
        "operation": "backup",
        "inputs": {},
        "result": {
          "content_sha256": "1cdf589e7391badf7d1c38af770df79b2fb4757f2d028eba9937696a8fc860d3"
        },
        "state_sha256": "1cdf589e7391badf7d1c38af770df79b2fb4757f2d028eba9937696a8fc860d3"
      },
      {
        "id": 19,
        "phase": "revoke",
        "operation": "remove",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-deadline"
        },
        "result": {
          "removed": true
        },
        "state_sha256": "fa8444aea1295a7195465c3517e5c96e9ce80fa86578d4b77988a1afacc8e07e"
      },
      {
        "id": 20,
        "phase": "revoke",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-deadline"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": false,
          "reason": "cache_miss"
        },
        "state_sha256": "fa8444aea1295a7195465c3517e5c96e9ce80fa86578d4b77988a1afacc8e07e"
      },
      {
        "id": 21,
        "phase": "revoke",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-brief"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": true,
          "reason": "cache_hit",
          "content": "Brief Atlas — Projet Atlas : livraison lundi. Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
        },
        "state_sha256": "fa8444aea1295a7195465c3517e5c96e9ce80fa86578d4b77988a1afacc8e07e"
      },
      {
        "id": 22,
        "phase": "revoke",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-language"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": true,
          "reason": "cache_hit",
          "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
        },
        "state_sha256": "fa8444aea1295a7195465c3517e5c96e9ce80fa86578d4b77988a1afacc8e07e"
      },
      {
        "id": 23,
        "phase": "restore",
        "operation": "restore",
        "inputs": {},
        "result": {
          "content_sha256": "1cdf589e7391badf7d1c38af770df79b2fb4757f2d028eba9937696a8fc860d3"
        },
        "state_sha256": "1cdf589e7391badf7d1c38af770df79b2fb4757f2d028eba9937696a8fc860d3"
      },
      {
        "id": 24,
        "phase": "restore",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-deadline"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": true,
          "reason": "cache_hit",
          "content": "Projet Atlas : livraison lundi."
        },
        "state_sha256": "1cdf589e7391badf7d1c38af770df79b2fb4757f2d028eba9937696a8fc860d3"
      },
      {
        "id": 25,
        "phase": "restore",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-brief"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": true,
          "reason": "cache_hit",
          "content": "Brief Atlas — Projet Atlas : livraison lundi. Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
        },
        "state_sha256": "1cdf589e7391badf7d1c38af770df79b2fb4757f2d028eba9937696a8fc860d3"
      },
      {
        "id": 26,
        "phase": "restore",
        "operation": "read",
        "inputs": {
          "key": "atlas-language"
        },
        "result": {
          "allowed": true,
          "reason": "cache_hit",
          "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
        },
        "state_sha256": "1cdf589e7391badf7d1c38af770df79b2fb4757f2d028eba9937696a8fc860d3"
      }
    ],
    "final_state_sha256": "1cdf589e7391badf7d1c38af770df79b2fb4757f2d028eba9937696a8fc860d3"
  },
  "shared_inputs": {
    "date_v1": "Projet Atlas : livraison vendredi.",
    "date_v2": "Projet Atlas : livraison lundi.",
    "language": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
  },
  "cases": [
    {
      "phase": "correct",
      "reference": {
        "before_rebuild": {
          "date": {
            "allowed": true,
            "reason": "cache_hit",
            "content": "Projet Atlas : livraison lundi."
          },
          "brief": {
            "allowed": true,
            "reason": "cache_hit",
            "content": "Brief Atlas — Projet Atlas : livraison vendredi. Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
          },
          "language": {
            "allowed": true,
            "reason": "cache_hit",
            "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
          }
        },
        "after_rebuild": {
          "date": {
            "allowed": true,
            "reason": "cache_hit",
            "content": "Projet Atlas : livraison lundi."
          },
          "brief": {
            "allowed": true,
            "reason": "cache_hit",
            "content": "Brief Atlas — Projet Atlas : livraison lundi. Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
          },
          "language": {
            "allowed": true,
            "reason": "cache_hit",
            "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
          }
        }
      },
      "persistent_memory": {
        "event_id": 3,
        "before_rebuild": {
          "date": {
            "allowed": true,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
              "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e"
            },
            "content": "Projet Atlas : livraison lundi.",
            "content_sha256": "642982ca12af2c09d877d5282c90717b65c047b89dad936b209bc967036d25ef",
            "reason": "allowed",
            "alias": null
          },
          "brief": {
            "allowed": false,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
              "version_id": "37c2519ef4f9406fb29a67910bf7a5a9"
            },
            "reason": "version_not_current"
          },
          "language": {
            "allowed": true,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
              "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0"
            },
            "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française.",
            "content_sha256": "8741943a03fa36d8d9eabfb540f080934cc4b79ecea11e830bd410744190abda",
            "reason": "allowed",
            "alias": null
          }
        },
        "after_rebuild": {
          "date": {
            "allowed": true,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
              "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e"
            },
            "content": "Projet Atlas : livraison lundi.",
            "content_sha256": "642982ca12af2c09d877d5282c90717b65c047b89dad936b209bc967036d25ef",
            "reason": "allowed",
            "alias": null
          },
          "brief": {
            "allowed": true,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
              "version_id": "3438f9a4324d43db8a7170e5de3d4478"
            },
            "content": "Brief Atlas — Projet Atlas : livraison lundi. Projet Atlas : langue de communication française.",
            "content_sha256": "de5e8bef42b39887b94fbec8e734a598efc71c101ace4d1b0f3f314a5e8d8e38",
            "reason": "allowed",
            "alias": null
          },
          "language": {
            "allowed": true,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
              "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0"
            },
            "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française.",
            "content_sha256": "8741943a03fa36d8d9eabfb540f080934cc4b79ecea11e830bd410744190abda",
            "reason": "allowed",
            "alias": null
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "phase": "revoke",
      "reference": {
        "after": {
          "date": {
            "allowed": false,
            "reason": "cache_miss"
          },
          "brief": {
            "allowed": true,
            "reason": "cache_hit",
            "content": "Brief Atlas — Projet Atlas : livraison lundi. Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
          },
          "language": {
            "allowed": true,
            "reason": "cache_hit",
            "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
          }
        }
      },
      "persistent_memory": {
        "event_id": 4,
        "after": {
          "date": {
            "allowed": false,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
              "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e"
            },
            "reason": "source_revoked"
          },
          "brief": {
            "allowed": false,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
              "version_id": "3438f9a4324d43db8a7170e5de3d4478"
            },
            "reason": "source_revoked"
          },
          "language": {
            "allowed": true,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
              "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0"
            },
            "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française.",
            "content_sha256": "8741943a03fa36d8d9eabfb540f080934cc4b79ecea11e830bd410744190abda",
            "reason": "allowed",
            "alias": null
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "phase": "restore",
      "reference": {
        "after": {
          "date": {
            "allowed": true,
            "reason": "cache_hit",
            "content": "Projet Atlas : livraison lundi."
          },
          "brief": {
            "allowed": true,
            "reason": "cache_hit",
            "content": "Brief Atlas — Projet Atlas : livraison lundi. Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
          },
          "language": {
            "allowed": true,
            "reason": "cache_hit",
            "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française."
          }
        }
      },
      "persistent_memory": {
        "event_id": 5,
        "before_verification": {
          "language": {
            "allowed": false,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
              "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0"
            },
            "reason": "authority_or_store_unavailable"
          }
        },
        "after": {
          "date": {
            "allowed": false,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-deadline",
              "version_id": "0049ca5a203e4370a49c68bd1e9acd0e"
            },
            "reason": "source_revoked"
          },
          "brief": {
            "allowed": false,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-brief",
              "version_id": "3438f9a4324d43db8a7170e5de3d4478"
            },
            "reason": "source_revoked"
          },
          "language": {
            "allowed": true,
            "ref": {
              "workspace": "portfolio-atlas",
              "artifact_id": "atlas-language",
              "version_id": "e33e752347fe441391e3089e53a835a0"
            },
            "content": "Projet Atlas : langue de communication française.",
            "content_sha256": "8741943a03fa36d8d9eabfb540f080934cc4b79ecea11e830bd410744190abda",
            "reason": "allowed",
            "alias": null
          }
        }
      }
    }
  ],
  "assertions": {
    "same_brief_inputs_derive": true,
    "same_brief_inputs_correct": true,
    "cache_old_brief_readable_before_rebuild": true,
    "core_old_brief_denied_before_rebuild": true,
    "both_briefs_correct_after_rebuild": true,
    "cache_source_removed": true,
    "cache_brief_retained_after_source_removal": true,
    "core_dependent_brief_denied_after_withdrawal": true,
    "cache_snapshot_restores_date_and_brief": true,
    "core_restored_date_and_brief_denied": true,
    "both_keep_independent_language": true
  },
  "provenance": {
    "fixture_sha256": "b0b3c92f53691c9284f55f21206cafb7812fc04d6a81dafa952cfdd27e9b8ce6",
    "example_script_sha256": "3c3cbdbc3916d155d390c96aedef55043e077704593afdb59a2807f8d6501f3e",
    "reference_receipts_sha256": "addee216a866ddecbfb0a621acfcf025d2d369d282b8c8ca4297c5378a0dd70a"
  },
  "boundaries": [
    "synthetic_application_example_without_model_or_network_calls",
    "storage_reopen_not_process_or_hardware_crash_simulation",
    "known_declared_dependencies_only",
    "current_authority_and_freshness_witness_retained_outside_content_backup",
    "coordinated_authority_and_witness_rollback_not_covered",
    "logical_read_revocation_not_physical_erasure_or_model_unlearning",
    "recorded_run_not_a_reliability_or_latency_benchmark",
    "illustrative_reference_contract_not_a_competitor_or_all_rag_systems",
    "both_receive_same_source_facts_explicit_brief_rebuild_withdrawal_and_content_restore",
    "core_retains_current_authority_and_witness_separately_reference_has_neither_by_contract",
    "cache_can_be_made_correct_by_explicit_rebuild_or_invalidation",
    "no_performance_durability_or_model_quality_comparison"
  ]
}